Black-Eyed Susan's Information

Stepping into Black-Eyed Susan's at 10 India St, Nantucket, MA, feels like being welcomed into a cozy, sunlit corner of the island where comfort meets charm. The atmosphere strikes a perfect balance between casual and refined, with warm wooden accents and an open, airy layout that makes it easy to relax whether you're grabbing a quick bite or lingering over a leisurely brunch. The menu leans into classic American breakfast and brunch favorites, but each dish shows thoughtful execution and a flair for fresh, local ingredients. The pancakes are fluffy without being heavy, the omelets are generously stuffed with crisp vegetables and quality cheeses, and the seafood options, including locally sourced lobster and crab, add a distinctive Nantucket touch. Service here feels genuinely attentive without hovering; staff are quick with recommendations and always ready to accommodate special requests, which makes busy weekend mornings surprisingly smooth. Coffee lovers will appreciate the robust, well-brewed cups that pair perfectly with everything from buttery pastries to savory breakfast skillets, and the seasonal specials highlight a creativity that keeps the menu feeling dynamic. Patrons often mention the friendly, welcoming vibe and the fact that the portions are satisfying without being overwhelming, making it an easy choice for families, couples, or solo diners. While the space can fill up quickly, especially during peak tourist season, the bustling energy only adds to the charm, giving you a sense of being part of a local ritual rather than a hurried meal. From the inviting interior to the thoughtfully curated menu, Black-Eyed Susan's blends island hospitality with reliably delicious food, creating an experience that captures the relaxed yet lively spirit of Nantucket dining.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

We had a great breakfast here. Of course, it’s Nantucket pricing, but that’s the whole island. I got the corned beef hash and it was unlike any other I’ve had. The corned beef was sooo tender and instead of using diced potatoes, they were almost mashed potatoes. Very good. Hubby got the huevos rancheros which had a really good sauce. He added an extra pancake too. The staff was very warm and kind. Seating was crowded but we really enjoyed our morning there.

Funky little spot with delicious made-to-order dishes. Innovative fare yet feels like home. The linguini with quahog clams were delicious—get the chocolate mousse dessert.

Saw the reviews so figured I would try it out. There was a short wait on a Sunday morning to get a seat. Place is small. Sat at counter. Had a guy wait on us, he seemed a little grumpy. In any case, I ordered the sourdough french toast and it was awesome. As were the sides. Overall it was a great spot to eat. I enjoyed the food. Coffee was also good.

Wow tucked away dining here it was like a breakfast show watching the two amazing chefs prepare food for a ton of people overflowing inside spurring out into a patio dining area outside. extremely busy tough location to park but absolutely amazing breakfast had scrambled eggs mixed with fresh broccoli potatoes and some light seasoning Curry with home fries wheat toast and of course a coffee with oat milk. Claire was my server we were sad at the bar and she did an incredible job set for one of the best breakfast I've ever eaten in Nantucket outside of cooking my own

Coming under new ownership, this spot has remained a Nantucket staple. Fantastic to get fish that really tastes fresh. Strong menu left me struggling to narrow down my choices! I definitely was ready to come back and order anything I did not get to try. Good portions and a casual environment for dinner. Make sure to book ahead as this place is certainly popular. I am excited to see what is to come for this spot and the return of breakfast!

Where do I begin! The coffee was absolutely delicious, the blueberry pancake tasted so fluffy and light, and the food was delicious! we were so pleased with our breakfast and service. The bar was so pleasant to sit at! We are going back this weekend after someone recommend the huevos rancheros to us!

Food was fantastic. Sat outside. Inside too hot to eat, but they accommodated us on the patio which was lovely.

The pancakes are great here, and there is a pretty good menu, too. We came early in the morning, and there was only a little wait. The only reason I didn’t give this place 5 stars was because we thought the inside area of the restaurant was pretty loud and crammed. We were all kind of shouting at each other at the table over other people talking and the chef banging his tools. So, if you can, I would ask for a table outside if you’re looking for a more relaxed experience. Their back patio looked quiet and more spacious.